Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
John Hartley
Mike,
Sorry to hear about your experience. Glad to see the video of you, hands on your hips, talking to the first responders. You did great, sir. I have a 21' flat bed aluminum trailer and a couple engine hoists in Kissimmee. If they can be of any assistance in your recovery efforts, please let me know. John Hartley 740-352-5752 Most of the money I've made in my life has been spent on airplanes. I wasted the rest.
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
You might take a look at the Amzoil racer incident. You will find it is not only a tandem wing design but
was constructed by RAF specifically with the features you are alluding to. There are some other
revisions since then that can also add margins, to a limit.
Survival has much has to do with time available to evaluate. Dave arriving at the FOD in Enid, now Mike.
The amount of
time to deal with a "7700" code is pertinent. I had my first in flight emergency rather early
in my piloting days (had just soloed 2 hours before with
a total of 7.5 hours in my logbook!), and it was at
possibly the worst time frame in any flight. But I learned each pilot who has experienced an in-flight emergency
had a problem "package" to deal
with and all of us can learn something very positive from their experiences.
Something that really bugs the hell out of me is the non-flying public doesn't understand is when a pilot that
is well versed and confident in the machine, then has an in-flight emergency, the training kicks in.. AFTER
some delay to realize what is happening, they have a very
good chance to survive. The airplane doesn't just
fall out of the sky in a "nose dive". The airplane probably won't survive, but
it is a machine and can be replaced.
It is expendable; but those below and inside are not, and in the midst of the emergency that is exactly the
mindset needed.
All of a sudden the "what if" becomes VERY real, and the survivor PIC always does this "fly the airplane first!"
In my case a rental Cessna 152 gave me a behind the instrument panel electrical fire, which quickly progressed
to a full on carpet
blaze and the cabin almost instantly full of stinging
and choking smoke. Once I realized the
emergency situation my training
kicked in. I hit the main buss, opened the window to evacuate the smoke
and
then had to beat the
flaming carpet fire out with my metal E6B! As Richard Prior once said..FIRE IS INSPIRATIONAL!
I did this all at about 600 feet, already past the runway, and
in a TRIMMED
climb (I stress that as I had practiced
and was trained to do, the aircraft was already trimmed
for best climb speed) and over a large area of residential housing
below. No idea how much fire I still had going on, or where,
but the airplane was still controllable and the
powerplant still operating.
First thing after the visible fire was out...fly airspeed best rate of climb away from the
residential, next level off, turn and
return, last was line up for the
grass downwind and prepare to abandon ship as soon as possible. I shut the engine and fuel
selector off in
the flare. BOTH off. There was no time for radio work and the main buss was off anyway. North Little Rock Municipal
was a non controlled field and is where I learned to fly from. The active was 18 that day, light breezes, CAVU.
Once below about 20 mph I unstrapped and took the exit
allowing the airplane to roll in the grass near the active past
me to a clear area from anyone or anything else. All of
this happened in less than probably 8 minutes time.
Years later I was fortunate enough to listen to Capt. Sully in person. An Airbus is a bit different than a Cessna. The forum
was totally dedicated and endorsed by the Seattle area F.A.A.
and I took the day off from work at Boeing to go. Totally
about emergency landing experiences as told by other pilots.
I would HIGHLY suggest any here who have not yet
done so to attend any such offerings
from the E.A.A. or F.A.A.
From the Aerospace Engineering side, Ian, we can only build in so much margin..and at the end of the day the
pilot in command is the key factor, and
that has been true if it says so or not in nearly every report you might read.
The CAUSE will be secondary to you at the moment of realization
the situation is going to result in an emergency landing.
The RESULT of what is on the 6 o'clock news is usually the person in the left seat.
In a race car the events happen so quickly there is very
little the driver can do other than relax and take
the ride. You
can't do that in an aircraft. Cars don't normally fly, conversely,
airplanes usually operate in three dimensions. But do take
a look at the Amzoil and the events it experienced at
Reno. We can improve of course...but the PIC is a very big part of the
improvements.
Ironically my job at the time at
Boeing I attended the F.A.A. Forum was Engineering protection due to in-flight cargo fires..to
protect the aircraft structure and systems long enough from cruise altitude so the crew could have a
chance at survival. That
ability was NOT the case in the 747-400 and earlier. Several of
747 versions prior to -8 have resulted in total fatalities due to
lithium battery fires
in the cargo areas. I was Lead M.E. in charge of
flammability testing and production on 747-8F and
747-8 Intercontinental. The
same is true on 777. both Freighter and Passenger built from about 2011 to now. I was also part of
the effort on those airacraft in the same cargo group.
So.. BIG time Kudos to Mike and also Dave! They both proved serious mettle in the heat of the moment. And yes... the News
people are big time drama vampires in my thinking. They are especially negative toward aviation in general and especially
toward general aviation!
Vern
From: main@Q-List.groups.io <main@Q-List.groups.io> on behalf of Ian Ashdown <ian.ashdown@...>
Sent: Friday, March 18, 2022 11:42 PM To: main@Q-List.groups.io <main@Q-List.groups.io> Subject: Re: [Q-List] Report of a Q-200 crash today Hi,
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Hi Mike, I agree that parts coming off is a good thing. I made my career in professional motorsports and we design the cars, F1 and Indy, to shed parts the dissipate energy. 200+mph against a concrete wall is a hard hit and we’ve made it survivable, but key to that is maintaining a ‘survival cell’, hence my thoughts about keeping the front bulkhead. I’d like to see the engine separate and get far away, but leave the structure intact.
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Mike Dwyer
Hi Bart, The ntsb wouldn't let me open it up to look, but I had an oil cooler hooked up with two flex lines to the engine. I suspect one line may have come loose and I was pumping oil overboard. My normal oil consumption was 8 hours per qt. And I took off with 5 qts. Mike Dwyer Q200
On Sat, Mar 19, 2022, 10:52 AM Bartholomew Hanson Fisher <fisherb@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Bartholomew Hanson Fisher
Mike any preliminary thoughts on oil pressure? In a little bit over 450 hours I have had one loss of oil pressure it was due to the remote oil filter assembly accessory plate warped causing air lock..... I was fortunate to shut it off and I did a total overhaul to verify everything’s was fine this was about 18 years ago. Oil sampling and compressions all good.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On Mar 19, 2022, at 8:38 AM, Mike Dwyer <q200pilot@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Mike Steinsland
Based on all your posts I know you really enjoyed flying that airplane. So sad to see all that come to an end for now. That airplane served you well even in the end. Still impressed by you and the others in this group that keep your head when things like this happen. Glad you're all right. God's not done with you yet. Cheers from the Great White North
On Sat., Mar. 19, 2022, 8:27 a.m. Mike Dwyer, <q200pilot@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Mike Dwyer
Ian, I liked the firewall tearing off. Fyi, when the canard ripped off it took the header tank with it and cracked the main tank so I had a total fuel spillage. No fire for 3 reasons. 1) had been gliding for a while and engine was off and cool. 2) landed on grass. 3) electrical design that I had not planned on. A large cable came up to the starter solenoid and was high up on the firewall, engine side. That wire stayed hot, so not great. Then I ran all the aircraft systems from a smaller hot wire that ran to a plug under the instrument panel. That plug separated in the crash basically shutting down everything. That turned out to be a good idea. Mike Dwyer Q200
On Sat, Mar 19, 2022, 12:42 AM Ian Ashdown <ian.ashdown@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Fredd Baber
Thanks Mike! Hope to catch up with you one day soon!!
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Fredd Baber
On Mar 19, 2022, at 8:27 AM, Mike Dwyer <q200pilot@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Mike Dwyer
Hi Fred, Best I can figure is the canard rotated downward, ripped off the firewall and all went under the plane. Maybe related to that gulley I went into. The wing tips hit first. Fly Safe, Mike
On Fri, Mar 18, 2022, 11:15 PM Fredd Baber <freddb43@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Raymond Johnson
I would happy to see these parts tear away if l were to crash my plane, it helps to cushion the impact . Well done Mick. Sent from my Samsung Mobile on the Telstra Mobile Network
-------- Original message -------- From: Ian Ashdown <ian.ashdown@...> Date: 19/3/22 3:42 pm (GMT+10:00) To: main@Q-List.groups.io Subject: Re: [Q-List] Report of a Q-200 crash today Hi,
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Hi,
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Fredd Baber
Mike,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Glad you’re ok. Never met but hope to one day soon. I’m down at KPGD and trying to get a ride in Adam Heidi’s Dfly one day soon. My question is how, when the canard was torn off, did your feet (and rudder pedals) not go with it?? Aren’t your feet sitting on top of it? Fredd Baber
On Mar 18, 2022, at 9:14 PM, Jay Scheevel <jay@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Good to have you back in a talking mood, Mike. You did good out there.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Cheers, Jay
On Mar 18, 2022, at 6:59 PM, Mike Dwyer <q200pilot@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Mike Dwyer
Thanks Mike. I should have kept a log of all the rides I've given. Only had one guy that had a death grip on the stick. I showed him how well two fingers work but he never got it. Y'all be safe out there! Mike Dwyer
On Fri, Mar 18, 2022, 8:37 PM Michael Dunning <dunningme@...> wrote: So glad to hear you're okay, Mike. To echo everyone else, having you here still with us is more important than the airplane ever was but it still stinks. Can't believe you walked out of that one when the whole FIREWALL was missing.
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Michael Dunning
So glad to hear you're okay, Mike. To echo everyone else, having you here still with us is more important than the airplane ever was but it still stinks. Can't believe you walked out of that one when the whole FIREWALL was missing.
I've actually been talking to a guy here in KHSV looking for your contact info. Khurram Aman wants to personally thank you for giving him his very first airplane ride in N3QP years ago and starting his love of aviation. Just condition inspected his T-67M260 today and he looked over #2827. He was amazed when he found out I was building the same type of plane 😢 -- -MD #2827 (still thinking about planning on visualizing how to finish building)
|
|
Re: Patty Wagstaff
Marianne Fox’s crash at SGJ happened on March 4. Patty Wagstaff posted on Facebook about it yesterday.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Russell Austin
On Mar 18, 2022, at 4:03 PM, Fredd Baber <freddb43@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Patty Wagstaff
Fredd Baber
Two plane crashes in FL in the same day?!?
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Fredd Baber
On Mar 18, 2022, at 3:35 PM, John Frank via groups.io <krtrcrfl@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Patty Wagstaff
John Frank
Not Really !
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On Mar 18, 2022, at 2:49 PM, Jim Patillo <Logistics_engineering@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Report of a Q-200 crash today
Martin Skiby
Very good job Mike! you are to be commended for putting it down exactly where you intended, after a no go to the airport. Glad you are OK!!!
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
----------------------------------------- From: "Mike Dwyer"To: main@q-list.groups.io Cc: Sent: Thursday March 17 2022 5:22:28PM Subject: Re: [Q-List] Report of a Q-200 crash today Just got this from our local CH8 news... That I was
kinda rude to. Told him I'm not going to say anything and
tried very hard to keep my back to them. Never talk
to reporters after a crash! I was actually going for
that road until all these cars showed up! And, darn, no
inside camera today. I don't know if I'd have taken the time
to turn it on anyway.
https://youtu.be/GZe2qIPWKUo
Mike Dwyer xQ200 N3QP
YouTube
Videos: https://www.youtube.com/user/FlyMeAirplane/videos
Q200 Website:
http://goo.gl/V8IrJF
On Thu, Mar 17, 2022 at 7:40 PM
Bruce Crain <jcrain2@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Patty Wagstaff
Thanks Nick. Thats great news!
Jim
N46JP Q200
Logistics Engineering and Design, Inc. Jim Patillo President/CEO 3987 First St. Suite H Livermore, CA 94551 Commercial General Contractor #662759 Office: 510-505-7800 Fax: 510-796-6516 Cell: 510-468-4891 Website: www.loginc.net Email: logistics_engineering@... ..."Every job is a self-portrait of the person who did it. Autograph your work with Excellence"....
From: main@Q-List.groups.io <main@Q-List.groups.io> on behalf of Nick Wright <nwright27@...>
Sent: Friday, March 18, 2022 11:23 AM To: main@Q-List.groups.io <main@Q-List.groups.io> Subject: Re: [Q-List] Patty Wagstaff There was an accident a couple days ago in St. Augustine (where Patty is based out of I believe) where a female aviator died after landing long. Wasn't Patty.
|
|