Date
1 - 20 of 29
aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4?
MartinErni@...
Wes,
The kit spinner was kevlar and is much tougher than alum. It does need a front bulkhead. Is that what you have or is it really fiberglass? Earnest
|
|
wesisberg <wes@...>
Hi -
For my Q200 I have a fibreglas spinner and bulkhead that I've decided to replace with aluminum (spinner, rear bulkhead and probably front bulkhead), most likely the Aircraft Spruce one mentioned by Sam Hoskins in http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Q-LIST/message/19334 i.e., http://www.aircraftspruce.com/catalog/appages/sn4.php If someone knows of a better (more timely?) alternative, let me know. (I considered getting the rear bulkhead and buying or making the front bulkhead and sticking with the fibreglas spinner, but I'm guessing I'd save at most a pound for the trouble.) Thanks - Wes
|
|
Peter Harris <peterjfharris@...>
I think balance is a big factor but not so easy to balance the cone.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Peter
----- Original Message -----
From: Jim Patillo To: Q-LIST@... Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 3:31 AM Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Sam, FYI, I've been using an aluminum spinner, aluminum backing plate and aluminum front bulkhead (wrapped with small diameter black rubber fuel hose)for 700+ hours now and have never had a problem. The front bulkhead/rubber hose to spinner is a fairly snug push on fit. Regards, Jim P. P.S. I've now converted the outer bushings on my ailerons and elevators from steel on steel bushings(factory)to Rulon on steel. It completely eliminated the up/down slop found on most all Q's. The controls are extremely smooth. I will keep everyone informed as I complete a 1 yr. test period. -- In Q-LIST@..., shoskins@m... wrote: > > Apparently the plate/tubing combination was not rock solid and some movement > occurred. This movement flexes the back plate and develops cracks. The cracks > appear as very thin black lines on the backplate, often around the > circumference of the crankshaft flange. > Sam > > > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org SPONSORED LINKS Aviation maintenance Aviation maintenance training Aviation maintenance schools Aviation maintenance schools Aviation Aviation art ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
MartinErni@...
Wes,
The rear bulkhead is kevlar also and I have never heard of one failing. Kevlar is tough as nails and will not crack. The biggest problem is cutting it. It takes very, very sharp tools. An easy way to make a front bulkhead is to make a sandwich of thin but dense foam with a layer of bid on each side. Then cut out a hole in the center that is the exact size of your prop crush plate. It has to fit tight and does not go under the plate, just fits around it. Then cut the outside diameter of the sandwich the same size as the spinner inside diameter at the crush plate location. This cut should be beveled to fit snuggly inside the spinner. When the spinner is installed the prop and crush plate hold the front bulkhead in one direction and the spinner holds it in the other. This way the front of the spinner can't move in any direction as long as you keep it a tight fit. Jerry Marstall used this method very successfully on his Q2. I would consider putting a flox closeout where the foam is exposed. Earnest
|
|
Wes,
You DO need to install a front bulkhead for your spinner. Talk to Brad Olsen about what happens when you don't. He didn't have one and his rear bulkhead failed (around the bolt pattern) on our way back from Oshkosh, leaving the spinner flopping around on his new prop. Fortunately I saw it just as we landed in Rapid City, SD. A couple more minutes and it would have failed and could have taken off the prop as it was already cutting into it. Jim Patillo N46JP Q200 P.S. All of the issues you keep asking about have been done and are readily solvable. Just look at the beautiful example next you and copy it! A no brainer. Remember there are more Q200's on your field than anywhere else on the earth. --- In Q-LIST@..., "wesisberg" <wes@c...> wrote: decided to replace with aluminum (spinner, rear bulkhead and probably frontHoskins in know. (I considered getting the rear bulkhead and buying or making the
|
|
wesisberg <wes@...>
Hi Jim -
Mainly I was hoping to hear of bulkheads I could get faster. I did talk with Brad and did plan the front bulkhead (make or buy). I try to do the research before posting so as not to waste people's time, but also I'd like to hear any objections in case I left something out (e.g., perhaps I should keep the *kevlar* spinner but use the SN-4 bulkheads, or buy the rear and make the front...). I have about 100 items on my todo list for 57RM, and I'm trying not to ask too much of you, Bob, Dave, et al. And if I did try to copy the beautiful machine next to mine, it would be more like 1000 todo items! Yours does give me something to aim for - after 57RM is flying again. Thanks - Wes --- In Q-LIST@..., "Jim Patillo" <logistics_engineering@m...> wrote:
|
|
wesisberg <wes@...>
Earnest,
The kit spinner is kevlar? I'll verify mine is, and try to keep it if so. Is the kit rear bulkhead kevlar? I've been assuming I should replace it with aluminum. I'll check that. As I hear it, the risk with composite bulkheads is that the material clamped under the bolts gets hot and soft, allowing the prop bolts to loosen, which makes more fretting/friction, leading to failure. (Are they also just more brittle/susceptible to cracking?) The aerocomposite (?) bulkheads report special multi-point bosses to avoid fretting; I'm not sure exactly what that means or whether it works, or whether it applies to the kit bulkhead (assuming ftm that's what I have). There are other FAA-certified composite bulkheads, so I'd expect there's some way to do them right. I'll certainly add a front bulkhead. Bob F. has told me how to make one from aluminum. Thanks - Wes --- In Q-LIST@..., MartinErni@a... wrote: does need a front bulkhead. Is that what you have or is it really fiberglass?
|
|
Leon - C <leon@...>
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
----- Original Message -----
From: "wesisberg" <wes@...> To: <Q-LIST@...> Sent: Wednesday, January 11, 2006 12:27 PM Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Earnest,The 2 I have here are just plain old glass. Both came with the kits when I got them, from 2 separate places, and look identical. So I am - assuming - that they were QAC originals. Doesn't mean that QAC didn't supply Kevlar ones........ ================= Leon McAtee
|
|
David Chalmers <David@...>
Wes, I installed the SN-4 a few years ago. I ordered the front bulkhead but my prop hub was too thick for it so I put the front bulkhead on the lathe and turned it down to the right size. This removed the nice flange that rests against the inside of the spinner so I got some small gauge nylon tubing, slit it down one side and pressed it over the edge of the front bulkhead disc all the way round. It makes a good fit with the inside of the spinner. You can use tubing with different wall thicknesses to adjust the fit. It has held up well so far.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I also have an unused, uncut, white 10" UHS fiberglass spinner (http://www.aircraftspruce.com/catalog/appages/uhs.php). It has a front bulkhead only (spinner is attached to front bulkhead) and is suitable for prop hubs less than 3.25" thick. It would work fine on a Q2 but my prop hub was too thick. If anyone wants it let me know. Dave Chalmers TriQ200 N4016G 250hrs Redmond WA
-----Original Message-----
From: wesisberg [mailto:wes@...] Sent: Wednesday, January 11, 2006 11:28 AM To: Q-LIST@... Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Earnest, The kit spinner is kevlar? I'll verify mine is, and try to keep it if so. Is the kit rear bulkhead kevlar? I've been assuming I should replace it with aluminum. I'll check that. As I hear it, the risk with composite bulkheads is that the material clamped under the bolts gets hot and soft, allowing the prop bolts to loosen, which makes more fretting/friction, leading to failure. (Are they also just more brittle/susceptible to cracking?) The aerocomposite (?) bulkheads report special multi-point bosses to avoid fretting; I'm not sure exactly what that means or whether it works, or whether it applies to the kit bulkhead (assuming ftm that's what I have). There are other FAA-certified composite bulkheads, so I'd expect there's some way to do them right. I'll certainly add a front bulkhead. Bob F. has told me how to make one from aluminum. Thanks - Wes --- In Q-LIST@..., MartinErni@a... wrote: does need a front bulkhead. Is that what you have or is it really fiberglass? Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org Yahoo! Groups Links
|
|
Sam Hoskins <shoskins@...>
In my experience Kevlar is very difficult to make clean non-fuzzy cuts. I
would recommend the aluminum spinner with the aluminum back plate. Spruce has a limited number of front plates available. As already mentioned, the geometry of the front plate is dependent on the prop thickness. There is a very long lead-time (months) ordering spinners and back plates from Spruce and they don't always fit perfectly. It might not hurt to order two back plates and keep one as a spare. Each one is custom made, since they drill the bolt pattern. The O-200 uses the SAE 1 pattern with 5/8" bushings. I tried the plastic tubing method for the front plant and it failed on me, so I fabricated my own front plate using Kevlar. Carbon fiber probably would have been a better choice. I installed nut plates and use four screws to attach the spinner to the front plate. I have probably installed six spinners in the last 20 years. For me, it's a real pain in the rear and gut wrenching experience. Overall, I am very dissatisfied with the ACS product support and customer service. If there was a suitable off-the-shelf composite spinner supplier I would sure like to meet them. Sam Hoskins Murphysboro, IL _____ From: Q-LIST@... [mailto:Q-LIST@...] On Behalf Of wesisberg Sent: Wednesday, January 11, 2006 12:30 PM To: Q-LIST@... Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Hi Jim - Mainly I was hoping to hear of bulkheads I could get faster. I did talk with Brad and did plan the front bulkhead (make or buy). I try to do the research before posting so as not to waste people's time, but also I'd like to hear any objections in case I left something out (e.g., perhaps I should keep the *kevlar* spinner but use the SN-4 bulkheads, or buy the rear and make the front...). I have about 100 items on my todo list for 57RM, and I'm trying not to ask too much of you, Bob, Dave, et al. And if I did try to copy the beautiful machine next to mine, it would be more like 1000 todo items! Yours does give me something to aim for - after 57RM is flying again. Thanks - Wes --- In Q-LIST@..., "Jim Patillo" <logistics_engineering@m...> wrote:
Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org SPONSORED LINKS Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance&w1=Aviation+mainte nance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Av iation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=NYqbfr CRSu-_RfVcTvi4nA> maintenance Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+training&w1=Aviati on+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+scho ols&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.s ig=UheaD83XCnCASim3ftrZHw> maintenance training Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviatio n+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schoo ls&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.si g=aX8ElLSzXlWeeJ4RuRL4kw> maintenance schools Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviatio n+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schoo ls&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.si g=aX8ElLSzXlWeeJ4RuRL4kw> maintenance schools Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Avi ation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Aviation+maint enance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=dx8FsS6KYgxHm3RuBm YoSA> Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+art&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2 =Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Aviation+m aintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=dRTZGQXiIldZ3q X6IHfOfQ> art _____ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS * Visit your group "Q-LIST <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Q-LIST> " on the web. * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... <mailto:Q-LIST-unsubscribe@...?subject=Unsubscribe> * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! <http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/> Terms of Service. _____
|
|
Ron <rondefly@...>
From my experience with resins and cloth, I would choose carbon fibre, I
surely believe it has the best qualities for a part like a spinner, I also agree with both plates, Once made the part should be balanced. That is probably why some are having a problem with the different materials cracking, I really think it is in the balance. Charlie, (One Sky Dog) made a beautiful carbon fibre one and I think he had them for sale a few years back, Think he monitors this list and the Dfly list. Keep Building Ron T _____ From: Q-LIST@... [mailto:Q-LIST@...] On Behalf Of Sam Hoskins Sent: Thursday, January 12, 2006 5:08 AM To: Q-LIST@... Subject: RE: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? In my experience Kevlar is very difficult to make clean non-fuzzy cuts. I would recommend the aluminum spinner with the aluminum back plate. Spruce has a limited number of front plates available. As already mentioned, the geometry of the front plate is dependent on the prop thickness. There is a very long lead-time (months) ordering spinners and back plates from Spruce and they don't always fit perfectly. It might not hurt to order two back plates and keep one as a spare. Each one is custom made, since they drill the bolt pattern. The O-200 uses the SAE 1 pattern with 5/8" bushings. I tried the plastic tubing method for the front plant and it failed on me, so I fabricated my own front plate using Kevlar. Carbon fiber probably would have been a better choice. I installed nut plates and use four screws to attach the spinner to the front plate. I have probably installed six spinners in the last 20 years. For me, it's a real pain in the rear and gut wrenching experience. Overall, I am very dissatisfied with the ACS product support and customer service. If there was a suitable off-the-shelf composite spinner supplier I would sure like to meet them. Sam Hoskins Murphysboro, IL _____ From: Q-LIST@... [mailto:Q-LIST@...] On Behalf Of wesisberg Sent: Wednesday, January 11, 2006 12:30 PM To: Q-LIST@... Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Hi Jim - Mainly I was hoping to hear of bulkheads I could get faster. I did talk with Brad and did plan the front bulkhead (make or buy). I try to do the research before posting so as not to waste people's time, but also I'd like to hear any objections in case I left something out (e.g., perhaps I should keep the *kevlar* spinner but use the SN-4 bulkheads, or buy the rear and make the front...). I have about 100 items on my todo list for 57RM, and I'm trying not to ask too much of you, Bob, Dave, et al. And if I did try to copy the beautiful machine next to mine, it would be more like 1000 todo items! Yours does give me something to aim for - after 57RM is flying again. Thanks - Wes --- In Q-LIST@..., "Jim Patillo" <logistics_engineering@m...> wrote:
Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org SPONSORED LINKS Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance&w1=Aviation+mainte &k=Aviation+maintenance&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Av iation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=NYqbfr CRSu-_RfVcTvi4nA> maintenance Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+training&w1=Aviati &k=Aviation+maintenance+training&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+scho ols&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.s ig=UheaD83XCnCASim3ftrZHw> maintenance training Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviatio &k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schoo ls&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.si g=aX8ElLSzXlWeeJ4RuRL4kw> maintenance schools Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviatio &k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schoo ls&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.si g=aX8ElLSzXlWeeJ4RuRL4kw> maintenance schools Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Avi &k=Aviation&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Aviation+maint enance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=dx8FsS6KYgxHm3RuBm YoSA> Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+art&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2 &k=Aviation+art&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Aviation+m aintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=dRTZGQXiIldZ3q X6IHfOfQ> art _____ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS * Visit your group "Q-LIST <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Q-LIST> " on the web. * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... <mailto:Q-LIST-unsubscribe@...?subject=Unsubscribe> * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! <http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/> Terms of Service. _____ Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org SPONSORED LINKS Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance&w1=Aviation+mainte nance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Av iation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=NYqbfr CRSu-_RfVcTvi4nA> maintenance Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+training&w1=Aviati on+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+scho ols&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.s ig=UheaD83XCnCASim3ftrZHw> maintenance training Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviatio n+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schoo ls&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.si g=aX8ElLSzXlWeeJ4RuRL4kw> maintenance schools Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviatio n+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schoo ls&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.si g=aX8ElLSzXlWeeJ4RuRL4kw> maintenance schools Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Avi ation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Aviation+maint enance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=dx8FsS6KYgxHm3RuBm YoSA> Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+art&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2 =Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Aviation+m aintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=dRTZGQXiIldZ3q X6IHfOfQ> art _____ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS * Visit your group "Q-LIST <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Q-LIST> " on the web. * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... <mailto:Q-LIST-unsubscribe@...?subject=Unsubscribe> * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! <http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/> Terms of Service. _____
|
|
Peter Harris <peterjfharris@...>
Well it is not really a point but a small dome. And we need to balance the back and front plates also. I think that generally not enough attention is given to the balancing of each part.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Peter
----- Original Message -----
From: Ron To: Q-LIST@... Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 6:48 AM Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? --- In Q-LIST@..., "Peter Harris" <peterjfharris@b...> wrote: > > I think balance is a big factor but not so easy to balance the cone. > Peter Peter, there is a point on the inside of the cone isn't there? Just like a tire balancer, support it with a point and spin it while watching the level line of the rear part of the spinner. Ron T > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Jim Patillo > To: Q-LIST@... > Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 3:31 AM > Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? > > > Sam, > > FYI, I've been using an aluminum spinner, aluminum backing plate and > aluminum front bulkhead (wrapped with small diameter black rubber fuel > hose)for 700+ hours now and have never had a problem. The front > bulkhead/rubber hose to spinner is a fairly snug push on fit. > > Regards, > > Jim P. > > P.S. I've now converted the outer bushings on my ailerons and elevators > from steel on steel bushings(factory)to Rulon on steel. It completely > eliminated the up/down slop found on most all Q's. The controls are > extremely smooth. I will keep everyone informed as I complete a 1 yr. > test period. > > > -- In Q-LIST@..., shoskins@m... wrote: > > > > Apparently the plate/tubing combination was not rock solid and some > movement > > occurred. This movement flexes the back plate and develops cracks. > The cracks > > appear as very thin black lines on the backplate, often around the > > circumference of the crankshaft flange. > > Sam > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site > http://www.quickiebuilders.org > > > > > > SPONSORED LINKS Aviation maintenance Aviation maintenance training Aviation maintenance schools > Aviation maintenance schools Aviation Aviation art > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------- > YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS > > a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. > > b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: > Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... > > c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------- > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Peter Harris <peterjfharris@...>
Thanks Jim. Sounds as if you have the means to balance as good as it gets.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Peter
----- Original Message -----
From: Jim Patillo To: Q-LIST@... Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 9:33 AM Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Peter, I have a Dynamic Prop Balancer which actually makes it fairly easy to balance the whole assembly in one step. The FAA calls for a balance if over 2.0 IPS (I think) for certified airplanes? Mine is balanced to .05 IPS with a near 0 phase angle. It makes the engine pretty smooth. The additional problem however, comes from the harmonics of the airframe as it cuts through the air. You can get a good ground balance and still have vibration at certain RPM's in the air. You just have to play with the dynamic balance to compensate. It would be so nice to be able to balance the whole thing in the air at a particular cruise speed. Regards, Jim --- In Q-LIST@..., "Peter Harris" <peterjfharris@b...> wrote: > > I think balance is a big factor but not so easy to balance the cone. > Peter > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Jim Patillo > To: Q-LIST@... > Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 3:31 AM > Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? > > > Sam, > > FYI, I've been using an aluminum spinner, aluminum backing plate and > aluminum front bulkhead (wrapped with small diameter black rubber fuel > hose)for 700+ hours now and have never had a problem. The front > bulkhead/rubber hose to spinner is a fairly snug push on fit. > > Regards, > > Jim P. > > P.S. I've now converted the outer bushings on my ailerons and elevators > from steel on steel bushings(factory)to Rulon on steel. It completely > eliminated the up/down slop found on most all Q's. The controls are > extremely smooth. I will keep everyone informed as I complete a 1 yr. > test period. > > > -- In Q-LIST@..., shoskins@m... wrote: > > > > Apparently the plate/tubing combination was not rock solid and some > movement > > occurred. This movement flexes the back plate and develops cracks. > The cracks > > appear as very thin black lines on the backplate, often around the > > circumference of the crankshaft flange. > > Sam > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site > http://www.quickiebuilders.org > > > > > > SPONSORED LINKS Aviation maintenance Aviation maintenance training Aviation maintenance schools > Aviation maintenance schools Aviation Aviation art > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------- > YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS > > a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. > > b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: > Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... > > c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------- > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Peter Harris <peterjfharris@...>
Jim I just realised I missread yout misspoke ! But if you can balance the whole of the assembly including the prop, the spinner and bulkheads that seems like the way to go ?
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Peter
----- Original Message -----
From: Jim Patillo To: Q-LIST@... Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 9:38 AM Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Sorry Peter,I mis-spoke. Thought you were talking about something else but then read the prior posts and realized my FU. Jim P. --- In Q-LIST@..., "Jim Patillo" <logistics_engineering@m...> wrote: > > > Peter, > > I have a Dynamic Prop Balancer which actually makes it fairly easy > to balance the whole assembly in one step. The FAA calls for a > balance if over 2.0 IPS (I think) for certified airplanes? Mine is > balanced to .05 IPS with a near 0 phase angle. It makes the engine > pretty smooth. > > The additional problem however, comes from the harmonics of the > airframe as it cuts through the air. You can get a good ground > balance and still have vibration at certain RPM's in the air. You > just have to play with the dynamic balance to compensate. > > > It would be so nice to be able to balance the whole thing in the air > at a particular cruise speed. > > Regards, > > Jim > > > --- In Q-LIST@..., "Peter Harris" <peterjfharris@b...> > wrote: > > > > I think balance is a big factor but not so easy to balance the > cone. > > Peter > > ----- Original Message ----- > > From: Jim Patillo > > To: Q-LIST@... > > Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 3:31 AM > > Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? > > > > > > Sam, > > > > FYI, I've been using an aluminum spinner, aluminum backing plate > and > > aluminum front bulkhead (wrapped with small diameter black > rubber fuel > > hose)for 700+ hours now and have never had a problem. The front > > bulkhead/rubber hose to spinner is a fairly snug push on fit. > > > > Regards, > > > > Jim P. > > > > P.S. I've now converted the outer bushings on my ailerons and > elevators > > from steel on steel bushings(factory)to Rulon on steel. It > completely > > eliminated the up/down slop found on most all Q's. The controls > are > > extremely smooth. I will keep everyone informed as I complete a > 1 yr. > > test period. > > > > > > -- In Q-LIST@..., shoskins@m... wrote: > > > > > > Apparently the plate/tubing combination was not rock solid and > some > > movement > > > occurred. This movement flexes the back plate and develops > cracks. > > The cracks > > > appear as very thin black lines on the backplate, often around > the > > > circumference of the crankshaft flange. > > > Sam > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site > > http://www.quickiebuilders.org > > > > > > > > > > > > SPONSORED LINKS Aviation maintenance Aviation maintenance > training Aviation maintenance schools > > Aviation maintenance schools Aviation Aviation art > > > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------------- -- > ----------- > > YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS > > > > a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. > > > > b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: > > Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... > > > > c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms > of Service. > > > > > > ----------------------------------------------------------------- -- > ----------- > > > > > > > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Peter Harris <peterjfharris@...>
No spinner looks unfinished and how about the effect on airflow into the cowl ?
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Peter
----- Original Message -----
From: David Chalmers To: Q-LIST@... Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 3:17 PM Subject: RE: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? I tried to measure the difference a few years back. It's hard to measure such a small change but I put it somewhere between 1/2 and 1mph at 170mph. Dave Chalmers TriQ200 N4016G 250hrs Redmond WA -----Original Message----- From: Mike Perry [mailto:dmperry1012@...] Sent: Thursday, January 12, 2006 9:01 PM To: Q-LIST@... Subject: RE: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? At 07:07 AM 1/12/2006 -0600, Sam Hoskins wrote: > {snip} >I have probably installed six spinners in the last 20 years. For me, it's a >real pain in the rear and gut wrenching experience. Overall, I am very >dissatisfied with the ACS product support and customer service. If there >was a suitable off-the-shelf composite spinner supplier I would sure like to >meet them. > >Sam Hoskins Has anyone compared performance with and without a spinner on a Q-2xx? I thought Mike Arnold said that he left the spinner off because it didn't help performance. Any comments? (haven't watched the AR-5 Videos in a couple of years, but I'm pretty sure he said that) Mike Perry Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org Yahoo! Groups Links Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
David Chalmers <David@...>
Sam, how did the plastic tubing method fail?
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Dave Chalmers TriQ200 N4016G 250hrs Redmond WA
-----Original Message-----
From: Sam Hoskins [mailto:shoskins@...] Sent: Thursday, January 12, 2006 5:08 AM To: Q-LIST@... Subject: RE: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? In my experience Kevlar is very difficult to make clean non-fuzzy cuts. I would recommend the aluminum spinner with the aluminum back plate. Spruce has a limited number of front plates available. As already mentioned, the geometry of the front plate is dependent on the prop thickness. There is a very long lead-time (months) ordering spinners and back plates from Spruce and they don't always fit perfectly. It might not hurt to order two back plates and keep one as a spare. Each one is custom made, since they drill the bolt pattern. The O-200 uses the SAE 1 pattern with 5/8" bushings. I tried the plastic tubing method for the front plant and it failed on me, so I fabricated my own front plate using Kevlar. Carbon fiber probably would have been a better choice. I installed nut plates and use four screws to attach the spinner to the front plate. I have probably installed six spinners in the last 20 years. For me, it's a real pain in the rear and gut wrenching experience. Overall, I am very dissatisfied with the ACS product support and customer service. If there was a suitable off-the-shelf composite spinner supplier I would sure like to meet them. Sam Hoskins Murphysboro, IL _____ From: Q-LIST@... [mailto:Q-LIST@...] On Behalf Of wesisberg Sent: Wednesday, January 11, 2006 12:30 PM To: Q-LIST@... Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Hi Jim - Mainly I was hoping to hear of bulkheads I could get faster. I did talk with Brad and did plan the front bulkhead (make or buy). I try to do the research before posting so as not to waste people's time, but also I'd like to hear any objections in case I left something out (e.g., perhaps I should keep the *kevlar* spinner but use the SN-4 bulkheads, or buy the rear and make the front...). I have about 100 items on my todo list for 57RM, and I'm trying not to ask too much of you, Bob, Dave, et al. And if I did try to copy the beautiful machine next to mine, it would be more like 1000 todo items! Yours does give me something to aim for - after 57RM is flying again. Thanks - Wes --- In Q-LIST@..., "Jim Patillo" <logistics_engineering@m...> wrote:
Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org SPONSORED LINKS Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance&w1=Aviation+mainte nance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Av iation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=NYqbfr CRSu-_RfVcTvi4nA> maintenance Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+training&w1=Aviati on+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+scho ols&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.s ig=UheaD83XCnCASim3ftrZHw> maintenance training Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviatio n+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schoo ls&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.si g=aX8ElLSzXlWeeJ4RuRL4kw> maintenance schools Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w1=Aviatio n+maintenance&w2=Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schoo ls&w4=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.si g=aX8ElLSzXlWeeJ4RuRL4kw> maintenance schools Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2=Avi ation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Aviation+maint enance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=dx8FsS6KYgxHm3RuBm YoSA> Aviation <http://groups.yahoo.com/gads?t=ms&k=Aviation+art&w1=Aviation+maintenance&w2 =Aviation+maintenance+training&w3=Aviation+maintenance+schools&w4=Aviation+m aintenance+schools&w5=Aviation&w6=Aviation+art&c=6&s=161&.sig=dRTZGQXiIldZ3q X6IHfOfQ> art _____ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS * Visit your group "Q-LIST <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Q-LIST> " on the web. * To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... <mailto:Q-LIST-unsubscribe@...?subject=Unsubscribe> * Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! <http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/> Terms of Service. _____ [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org Yahoo! Groups Links
|
|
shoskins@...
Apparently the plate/tubing combination was not rock solid and some movement
occurred. This movement flexes the back plate and develops cracks. The cracks appear as very thin black lines on the backplate, often around the circumference of the crankshaft flange. Sam
|
|
Sam,
FYI, I've been using an aluminum spinner, aluminum backing plate and aluminum front bulkhead (wrapped with small diameter black rubber fuel hose)for 700+ hours now and have never had a problem. The front bulkhead/rubber hose to spinner is a fairly snug push on fit. Regards, Jim P. P.S. I've now converted the outer bushings on my ailerons and elevators from steel on steel bushings(factory)to Rulon on steel. It completely eliminated the up/down slop found on most all Q's. The controls are extremely smooth. I will keep everyone informed as I complete a 1 yr. test period. -- In Q-LIST@..., shoskins@m... wrote: movement occurred. This movement flexes the back plate and develops cracks.The cracks appear as very thin black lines on the backplate, often around the
|
|
steve <sham@...>
Jim, Where did you buy your Rulon. Do they make bushings or did you fabricate yours?
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Steve Ham
----- Original Message -----
From: Jim Patillo To: Q-LIST@... Sent: Thursday, January 12, 2006 12:31 PM Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Sam, FYI, I've been using an aluminum spinner, aluminum backing plate and aluminum front bulkhead (wrapped with small diameter black rubber fuel hose)for 700+ hours now and have never had a problem. The front bulkhead/rubber hose to spinner is a fairly snug push on fit. Regards, Jim P. P.S. I've now converted the outer bushings on my ailerons and elevators from steel on steel bushings(factory)to Rulon on steel. It completely eliminated the up/down slop found on most all Q's. The controls are extremely smooth. I will keep everyone informed as I complete a 1 yr. test period. -- In Q-LIST@..., shoskins@m... wrote: > > Apparently the plate/tubing combination was not rock solid and some movement > occurred. This movement flexes the back plate and develops cracks. The cracks > appear as very thin black lines on the backplate, often around the > circumference of the crankshaft flange. > Sam > > > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org SPONSORED LINKS Aviation maintenance Aviation maintenance training Aviation maintenance schools Aviation maintenance schools Aviation Aviation art ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Bob Farnam <bfarnam@...>
As another point of info regarding the use of tubing on the front spinner
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
bulkhead, I also had failures when I used Tygon tubing. When I switched to polyurethane tubing, the problems went away. Urethane has much higher cut and abrasion resistance. I have about 250 hours on the urethane and it still looks good. Bob F. N200QK EAA Flight Advisor
-----Original Message-----
From: Q-LIST@... [mailto:Q-LIST@...]On Behalf Of Jim Patillo Sent: Thursday, January 12, 2006 9:31 AM To: Q-LIST@... Subject: [Q-LIST] Re: aluminum spinner - ACS SN-4? Sam, FYI, I've been using an aluminum spinner, aluminum backing plate and aluminum front bulkhead (wrapped with small diameter black rubber fuel hose)for 700+ hours now and have never had a problem. The front bulkhead/rubber hose to spinner is a fairly snug push on fit. Regards, Jim P. P.S. I've now converted the outer bushings on my ailerons and elevators from steel on steel bushings(factory)to Rulon on steel. It completely eliminated the up/down slop found on most all Q's. The controls are extremely smooth. I will keep everyone informed as I complete a 1 yr. test period. -- In Q-LIST@..., shoskins@m... wrote: > > Apparently the plate/tubing combination was not rock solid and some movement > occurred. This movement flexes the back plate and develops cracks. The cracks > appear as very thin black lines on the backplate, often around the > circumference of the crankshaft flange. > Sam > > > > > > > Quickie Builders Association WEB site http://www.quickiebuilders.org SPONSORED LINKS Aviation maintenance Aviation maintenance training Aviation maintenance schools Aviation maintenance schools Aviation Aviation art ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS a.. Visit your group "Q-LIST" on the web. b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: Q-LIST-unsubscribe@... c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --
|
|